Crest True Value Hardware558 Metropolitan @ Lorimer, Brooklyn (
map)(
website)
Crest is a great neighborhood hardware store. The prices are good and the people working there are friendly and helpful. I went on a weekday and one of the employees took the time to answer all of my novice gardening questions and I learned that potted plants require potting soil and not garden soil.
Crest has an excellent selection of gardening supplies, pretty much everything that you would need to setup a patio or even outdoor garden and they also carry organic gardening supplies. Plus, they've got real, honest to goodness plants, including herbs! In addition to the display in front, there is a garden patio in the rear of the store.
Sprout Home44 Grand Street, Brooklyn (
map)(
website)

Check out some unaffiliated to me photos of Sprout on Flickr:
Sprout Home Flickr SetStores like Sprout Home are why I live in Williamsburg. It is so frickin' cute. Sprout is what I imagine when I think of "Urban Gardening", selective, small, creative and beautiful. If you want your plants to be hip, eclectic and dressed in the coolest, well pots, Sprout is your place. If you want to look as good as your plants, while tending to your plants, Sprout has got you covered. Also, Sprout carries a small, precious selection of housewares and furnitues. We got our
shower curtain from Sprout (though we had to order it online, since the Brooklyn store was out of stock).
Sprout is well-stocked and only walking distance from our apartment in Northside Williamsburg. Between Sprout and Crest Hardware our neighborhood is well covered. We got our two heirloom tomato plants, organic potting soil, organic tomato food, and some of our bamboo stakes from Sprout. The prices are reasonable (ok, you pay a tiny bit more for the cute-o-sity).
The only downside ... mosquitoes. Got got by them critters. Skeeters are especially
bad this year.
An extra bonus, Sprout is right next to the A.P.C outlet,
Two Jakes and
Moon River Chattel. The Williamsburg version of the IKEA / Expo Design / Home Depot run in Emeryville.
Khim's Market280 Bedford @ N. 1st St (
map)(
site)

Small selection of plants, including tomato, chiles and pepper and a few herbs. They had non-organic potting soil, but only a few pots.
Khim's is mostly a small grocery that also sells plants during the summer.
Unnamed place next to Om Sweet Om(edit: walked by there on Sept 13, 2008 and the place now has signage and is called "Jungle")57 Kent Avenue-ish, Brooklyn (
map)(
website)
Helen's friend, Jane, had a car and she was nice enough to take us drive us around Williamsburg and Greenpoint last month. It was really cool zipping around in a car and seeing more of North Brooklyn in 15 minutes than in our first 2 months here (some would say that I am kind of a shut-in). During our car tour, we saw a huge garden center just a couple of blocks away from where we live on Kent and N. 10th St.
We tried to check it out after the MGMT @ McCarren Pool thingy, but it was already closed. It is right next to Om Sweet Om, but I don't actually think they are related. About a week later we got there when it was still open.
This place was part garden lounge and nursery with an eclectic selection of plants. It kinda reminded me of
Flora Grubb in SF, but w/o an indoor space and unfortunately no
Ritual Coffee. They mostly carry really big plants and pots and maybe don't have all the garden supplies that you would need, but has cool stuff.
We were trying to buy some organic fertilizer for our tomatoes, but they only had a 30 lb bag. The price seemed good considering the fertilizer seemed like good stuff.
Home Depot, ChelseaOne of the things about Williamsburg is that without a car, it can be easier to get to Manhattan than other parts of Brooklyn that are not off the L.
This is one of the urban Home Depots, but they had a pretty decent urban gardening section as far as supplies go. I found medium sized planters and organic potting soil and plant food (along with the non-organic kind). There was a run on organic potting soil b/c both the Home Depot Chelsea and Crest True Value were out at one point when I went to buy. The plant selection is geared towards apartment plants and there were no tomato plants or herbs.
The location of this Home Depot is excellent, within a couple of blocks of the Container Store and Bed, Bath and Beyond ... Home improving is the new sexy.
Also, if you want to wait an hour for a burger, the Shake Shack is half a block away.
Home Depot, Bed-StuyHave not been, but apparently has a garden center.
Hardware Store on BedfordLimited selection of pots (a few window boxes), but they did have a small bag of organic potting soil.